.

.

Welcome to the House of Flavors

A little bit background - because of a chronic stomach condition, I haven't been able to eat ice cream in ten years. TEN YEARS. Imagine my suffering.

But after years of seeing a nutritionist and trying dozens of different diets and herbal remedies, my stomach has slowly been healing, and I am once again able to eat frozen deliciousness made from milk and cream and sugar. I am ecstatic, which I'm sure any ice cream lover can understand.

When I discovered I could once again eat ice cream without getting sick, I came up with the brilliant idea that I would undertake an epic taste test of Ben & Jerry's dozens of ice cream flavors. And starting with this original taste test, this blog is where I record and review all results of my ice cream taste testing adventures. Enjoy my rapturous observations about each delicious flavor and please feel free to share your own opinions in the comments section!
Showing posts with label Chunky Ice Creams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chunky Ice Creams. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 5, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Peppermint Crunch

Chocolate Peppermint Crunch is Ben & Jerry's latest foray into the territory of chocolate and mint flavor combinations - an ongoing experiment with this traditionally popular combo that has included the now-retired flavors Chocolate Mint & Cookies, Chocolate Mystic Mint, Mint Chocolate Chunk, Mint Chocolate Fudge Swirl, Mint Fudge and Mint with Oreo Cookie, as well as the currently available flavor Mint Chocolate Cookie. Looking over this list, you might begin to wonder why Ben & Jerry's has gone through so many variations on the same chocolate and mint theme, but I would venture to guess that it's not because any of these flavors failed to sell. Ben and Jerry simply seem to enjoy working and reworking a combination, like cooks who change the spices in the stew just a little bit each time. And while most Mint Chocolate Chip ice creams produced by most ice cream manufacturers are pretty much interchangeable with all other Mint Chocolate Chip ice creams, the two Ben & Jerry's chocolate and mint flavors that I have now sampled are both a great deal different from your average carton of Mint Chocolate Chip.

I first sampled Mint Chocolate Cookie, which with its small chunks and crushed bits of Oreo is a few steps up from plain Jane Mint Chocolate Chip. Seeing a second chocolate and mint combo on the market at the same time made me curious to find out what the difference was between Mint Chocolate Cookie and Chocolate Peppermint Crunch, simce both combine chocolate, peppermint, fudge and cookie elements. Time for an exercise in Compare and Contrast.

As I sampled Chocolate Peppermint Crunch, two notable differences presented themselves. First of all, while Mint Chocolate Cookie has a mint ice cream base just like the traditional Mint Chocolate Chip flavor, Chocolate Peppermint Crunch has a chocolate ice cream base with peppermint and fudge swirls running throughout. While the fudge swirl do not stand out in any discernible way from the chocolate ice cream itself, the peppermint swirl have the effect of basically turning the base flavor into a delicious hybrid of chocolate peppermint ice cream. I'm definitely a fan.

The second difference that I noticed with this flavor is the presence of the mint chocolate cookie balls. I was expecting that the cookie balls would probably resemble the softer cookie dough in Half Baked, the cookie swirls in Milk & Cookies, or the Oreo cookie in Mint Chocolate Cookie. But this is where Ben & Jerry's has made a big change that makes this flavor a lot more of a fun experience to sample. Like Chubby Hubby, eating Chocolate Peppermint Crunch makes me feel as though I am going on a treasure hunt. Because the cookie balls are actually about as big as malted milk balls and as crunchy as the pretzel pieces in Chubby Hubby, you end up really having to dig your way through the pint of Chocolate Peppermint Crunch.  It takes something of an effort to scoop out those cookie balls, but for those of us who enjoy that kind of thing, Chocolate Peppermint Crunch is a whole lot of fun to eat.  You actually end up chomping on this frozen dairy delight.

As for the balance between chocolate and mint, Ben & Jerry's has done an excellent job yet again of finding the perfect blend between the two flavors. As I explained in my original review of mint chocolate cookie, I am very picky about the peppermint to chocolate ratio in my chocolate and mint desserts. I adore Thin Mints and Andes Mints, but there is too much nasty peppermint paste in York Peppermint Patties amd Ghirardelli Chocolate Peppermint Squares for my taste. So I am very pleased that Ben & Jerry's seems to understand the proper ratio between the two flavors that will please my taste buds.  Of the two B&J's mint and chocolate flavors that are currently on the market, I like this one even better than Mint Chocolate Cookie because it's more chocolatey. The best description that I can come up with to describe this delicious flavor is that it is like Christmas in my mouth, and that is high praise indeed, coming from someone who loves Christmas as much as I do.

Because of the excellent job combining chocolate and mint, and even more because those crunchy cookie balls make this flavor so much fun to eat, I give Chocolate Peppermint Crunch 4.5 stars.  This is another chunky paragon of the Ben & Jerry's brand that joyfully reinvents I tradition and makes my mission to sample all of their flavors so much fun.

Tuesday, October 28, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Chubby Hubby

Digging in to a pint of Ben & Jerry's Chubby Hubby is a lot like embarking on a treasure hunt. With full-sized pretzel bites covered in chocolate and buried throughout the pint, this flavor has the largest chunks of any B&J's ice cream that I have sampled thus far, and you really do have to dig for those pretzels to get them out of there. While some people may mind that the pretzels make Chubby Hubby fairly difficult to scoop, I enjoyed the experience of having to put a little more of my muscle to work in order to retrieve my buried treasure from the pint. Once extracted from the vanilla malt ice cream with fudge and peanut butter swirls, those pretzel bites are a great reward. They remain surprisingly light, airy and crisp in the ice cream, and provide just a hint of salty flavor to complement all the sweetness. Given my opinion that the chunkiest flavors provide the quintessential Ben & Jerry's experience, I consider Chubby Hubby to be a paragon of the brand.

And then there is the ice cream itself.  While I'm not a fan of plain vanilla ice cream, this vanilla malt has enough fudge and peanut butter swirls to satisfy my craving for something rich, without being overpowering in its decadence. In my first few months of taste testing ice creams, I've learned that I passionately love any flavor with peanut butter chunks, cups or flavor swirls, whether or not the PB is combined with chocolate. It should go without saying, though, that chocolate is an added bonus, and so Chubby Hubby gets a high rating in huge part because of the tasty peanut butter and fudge swirls.

I have to note, however, that at 340 calories per serving, Chubby Hubby is one of the Ben & Jerry's flavors that you have to work even harder/longer to burn when it's time to exercise. Many of my favorite B&J's flavors run from 260 to 290 per serving, and that difference in calories can really start to add up, especially if you want to enjoy more than one serving. As my husband pointed out, Chubby Hubby is aptly named, because "that is what you are going to have if you keep buying all this ice cream!" (The poor man has it so hard, putting up with a wife who constantly wants him to sample yet another delicious Ben & Jerry's flavor.) But because of the higher calorie content, I found that one of the advantages to having to dig through the pint of Chubby Hubby for the pretzel bites is that it takes longer to eat a single half-cup serving, so I felt more satisfied after eating a smaller amount of the ice cream. So the treasure hunt when eating Chubby Hubby is more than just a fun experience - it can also help you stretch that pint across an extra day or two and consume fewer calories at one sitting. At least in theory.

Overall, I give Chubby Hubby a four star rating, which for me is based primarily on the combo of peanut butter and fudge, but also on the satisfying reward of crunchy pretzel bites. I just don't think I'll be buying this flavor quite as often, since on a bad day, I may not be able to resist eating more than one serving.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Nutty Caramel Swirl

When I made a special pilgrimage to 7-Eleven (of which there are sadly none located close to my home) to pick up their exclusive Ben & Jerry's flavor Nutty Caramel Swirl, I learned an important lesson in ice cream economics - when a retailer has the market cornered on Ben & Jerry's, they can charge even more exorbitant prices than the already pricey $4 per pint that B&J's costs on average. After standing in line behind an adorable but frustrating elderly gentleman who slowly counted out each penny in good old fashioned change for his purchase, while I stood fidgeting and hoping that the other 3 pints of Ben & Jerry's in my car hadn't yet turned into puddles of delicious stain on the floor of the passenger side, I ended up paying $5.50 for a pint of Nutty Caramel Swirl. My thoughts as I left the 7-Eleven were running along the lines of "this flavor had better be worth that $5.50 and any additional monetary losses that I incur in melted ice cream and car mat cleaning."

Later that evening, I was trying to decide which of the four new flavors to sample, when the description of Nutty Caramel Swirl caught my eye - "nougat ice cream with peanuts, fudge flakes and a salty caramel swirl." Hmmm. "What the h*ll is nougat ice cream?" I asked my husband, a little bit perturbed. "Nougat is that chocolate stuff in candy bars," he answered, nonplussed despite my confusion and somewhat irrational annoyance with Ben & Jerry's for labeling a package with an unhelpful description.  "So it probably tastes like chocolate," he reasoned. Hmmm. I opened the pint and stared at the ice cream, which resembled the rich chocolate Ben & Jerry's ice cream not a bit. "I'm not convinced," I told him - but he had stopped caring by that point. So I was left on my own to make this all-important flavor determination. Nougat flavored ice cream was puzzling, mysterious and intriguing,  so clearly I had found the flavor to sample for the evening's taste test. Maybe there was a very good reason that Ben & Jerry's had chosen a less readily identifiable way of describing this flavor - the more curious you are about the flavor, the more you have to try it and the more willing you are to shell out that $5.50 per pint for an Exclusive Flavor.

Nougat ice cream doesn't quite live up to its mysterious name, though - as I ate up a third of the pint of Nutty Caramel Swirl, I didn't detect that it had a distinctive flavor. Instead, the indeterminate nougat ice cream gave center stage to the chunks of peanut and fudge that were enough to make this flavor positively crunchy. The peanut flavor is distinct from other Ben & Jerry's flavors that I've sampled with peanut butter flavoring - there is something very different from the strong nutty taste (thus the name of this flavor) from the sweeter, creamier flavor of peanut butter in B&J's Peanut Butter Jam Session or Banana Peanut Butter Greek Froyo, for example.

But while the "Nutty" in the name "Nutty Caramel Swirl" is the extremely accurate part of the flavor's name, slapping the word "Caramel" in the title is far less accurate, at least according to what I cpuld taste.  The caramel swirl is underwhelming, to say the least, and without much caramel, this ends up being a far less sweet flavor of ice cream. Not that it's bad to have a flavor that doesn't make your teeth buzz and immediately fall out of your jaw, but it's something to keep in mind when selecting your pint of ice cream, especially before you fork over that $5.50 at 7-Eleven. But if you want a more chunky, crunchy quintessential Ben & Jerry's ice cream experience, this is the flavor for you, since it even tops Chunky Monkey with its extreme crunch favor. It's not just the peanuts that are crunchy, either - those fudge chunks are equally loud as you chomp down on them.

Verdict? Nutty Caramel Swirl is a tasty flavor with a lot of satisfying chunks, and is worth the occasional pilgrimage to 7-Eleven and $5.50 per pint if you're in the mood for something particularly nutty. But is this going to join the regular rotaation in my freezer? Nah. At 3.5 stars, Nutty Caramel Swirl loses out to Phish Food with its higher chocolate quotient and stronger gooey caramel flavoring almost every time.

Monday, October 20, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Phish Food

After a long and overwhelming day at work, I went digging through the Ben & Jerry's pints stacked in my freezer, trying to decide which flavor would best soothe my nerves and help repair my mood. It had to be something decadent, a flavor with some serious chocolate. Because as all women know (at least instinctively), cocoa has a significantly uplifting effect on a person's brain chemistry and mood. This has been scientifically proven, so don't bother to argue with me about the medical and psychological value of chocolate ice cream. Ben & Jerry's can be a very effective treatment for many ailments, both physical and emotional - it's a fact.

I decided to try Phish Food. To be honest, the name of this flavor has always kind of turned me off because it always makes me think of the brightly colored Beta fish named Buffy, Angel and Spike that my husband and I owned for several years and who met an untimely death without attracting my attention for several weeks because I was in grad school at the time. But that's a tangent that I don't need to follow any further, because this is a blog about ice cream, not funny stories about pet mishaps.

The description on the carton of Phish Food, which reads, "chocolate ice cream with gooey, marshmallow swirls, caramel swirls and fudge fish," sounded like it would be more than decadent enough.  I was fairly certain that it would be more rich than my current favorite flavor of Ben & Jerry's chocolate ice cream, which is Chocolate Fudge Brownie.  And I was not wrong.  While I couldn't distinctly taste the marshmallow swirls (which was a bit of a disappointment), the typically rich nature of Ben & Jerry's chocolate ice cream, in this case laced with gooey caramel, is enough to send me happily into a benign sugar coma.

Then there are those fudge fish. The flavor's phish/fish theme seems to me to be a true oddity that comes out of left field. (Why associate your ice cream with seafood?!?!! What were Ben and Jerry thinking?!) Yet when it comes right down to it, those fudge fish are big chunks of chocolate - bigger by far than the fudge flakes in Cherry Garcia and bigger than even the hefty little bricks of chocolate in Chunky Monkey. Well done, Ben and Jerry. Well done.

In summary, Phish Food is a truly decadent flavor that I may not crave constantly, but that I will definitely buy when my hormones go all wonky at a certain time of the month. This flavor gets 4 stars for its gooey and delicious combo of chocolate and caramel.

Saturday, October 18, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Cinnamon Buns

Oh. My. Lord.

I didn't think that I would ever find an ice cream flavor that I love quite as passionately as Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Jam Session, but it has indeed happened.  Cinnamon Buns is now tied with PBJS for my most favoritest ice cream flavor of all time.  Amazingly enough, neither one of these flavors has even the teensiest bit of chocolate in it.  I can't even begin to tell you how shocking that is to me.  But with its caramel ice cream, chunks of cinnamon bun dough and cinnamon streusel swirls, Cinnamon Buns doesn't need any chocolate.  (Did I really just say that?!)  

A friend of mine had recently recommended Cinnamon Buns as a must-try Ben & Jerry's flavor, saying that for several months, she and her husband had been buying a pint every week. Until they realized that their pants just kept getting tighter and tighter. While that sounded like the ideal recommendation to me, I still didn't expect that I would fall so completely in love with Cinnamon Buns. But each bite of this flavor is a delicious burst of sweet cinnamon, blended with a light caramel, that sends me to gastronomic heaven.

There's nothing very unexpected about the flavor, which tastes exactly like someone went to Cinnabon, stole a carton of their dough, and mixed it up with some rich vanilla-caramel Ben & Jerry's ice cream. But while the descriptions of some Ben & Jerry's flavors sound completely amazing and then end up disappointing me (for example, Coconut Seven Layer Bar and Volun-Tiramisu), Cinnamon Buns is a flawlessly and deliciously executed flavor that exceeds my expectations.  Just look at these chunks of cinnamon bun dough, which are plentiful throughout the ice cream -


These little balls of cinnamon dough are exquisite, and the pictures should make it clear that with Cinnamon Buns, Ben & Jerry's has come up with a heavenly recipe.  Cinnamon streusel + cinnamon dough + ice cream blended to perfection. In fact, I think that if I gave myself free rein, I could eat Ben & Jerry's Cinnamon Buns in greater quantities than I could eat actual Cinnabons or homemade cinnamon rolls, which are amazingly delicious but sometimes overwhelm my taste buds with all the gooey frosting. With their Cinnamon Buns flavor, Ben and Jerry have come up with a perfectly rich, perfectly balanced (at least for my palette) treat.

Do I even need to say it? This flavor gets 5 stars and a permanent spot in my freezer.

Wednesday, October 15, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Chunky Monkey

I honestly wasn't expecting to enjoy Chunky Monkey nearly as much as I ended up enjoying it, despite preference for unusual ice cream flavors and combinations. I should have realized that if a banana split, with its sweet marriage of bananas and ice cream, is such an amazing treat, then banana ice cream is basically the brilliant idea to take that idea to the next level. Previously excellent partners in marriage, bananas and ice cream truly become one in Ben & Jerry's Chunky Monkey, with quite pleasing and successful results.

The banana ice cream itself was the best surprise for my palette, since I wasn't expecting it to taste much different than my healthy breakfast banana protein shake.  But above and beyond the sweet and creamy banana ice cream are the large chunks of fudge and walnuts. Please note my emphasis on both of the words large and chunks.  Some Ben & Jerry's flavors have "fudge flakes," which is code for "tiny, thin pieces."  But one of my favorite things about the experience of eating Ben & Jerry's ice cream is the chunky pieces combined with the creamy texture of many of the flavors, producing a particularly pleasing "mouth feel" (a food industry term that means exactly what you would think that it means - how a food feels in your mouth, and how that contributes to your enjoyment of that food).  Sometimes I feel like the Ben & Jerry's flavors that skimp on the chunks are missing something that is quintessentially Ben & Jerry's. Somehow there are B&J's flavors that aren't truly Ben & Jerry's enough.  But that is not the case with Chunky Monkey, as the name assures.  Those large chunks of fudge and walnuts are big enpugh to satisfy even this particularly picky fan of chunky ice cream, earning this flavor a solid 4 star rating.

Thursday, October 9, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie

It may not be quite as unique as some Ben & Jerry's flavors, but with its chunks of chewy, fudgy brownie pieces in rich chocolate ice cream, originality be damned. Chocolate Fudge Brownie gets a rating of 5 stars and a permanent spot in my freezer.  These days, since this is also my husband's favorite of the Ben & Jerry's flavors that we have sampled so far, we've actually been making room for more than one pint at a time of Chocolate Fudge Brownie in our freezer.  Yes, it's that good.  While the brownie chunks are definitely the highlight of this flavor, I have to say that Ben & Jerry's basic chocolate ice cream is also the best that I've ever tasted.  Up until now, I have always considered chocolate ice cream to be a bit... well, boring.  There it is - my confession of the day.  But in Ben & Jerry's hands, this basic flavor has become something richer, creamier and somehow more chocolaty than regular chocolate ice cream.  So both the ice cream base and the fudgy brownies of Chocolate Fudge Brownie are an immense treat.

A fun coincidence - the brownies in B&J's Chocolate Fudge Brownie ice cream are baked by Greyston Bakery, a non-profit organization in Yonkers, New York, which provides employment and job training to economically disadvantaged residents.  I work in Yonkers, so now I know where to go if I want a good brownie.  And these are definitely good brownies.  I cannot use italics enough in this ice cream review to adequately convey my love of the fudgy, fudgy brownies in this flavor.




An additional important note - we've gone through several pints of Chocolate Fudge Brownie in the past several weeks, and all but one of the pints had delicious, fudgy brownie chunks. But one of the pints that I bought had dry, crumbly brownie pieces.  Alas, the brownies had been the victim of horrible freezer burn.  So be forewarned - if you come across a pint of Chocolate Fudge Brownie with less-than-fudgy brownies, that's a decidedly abnormal batch.  Don't base your judgement on this delicious flavor based on a freezer burned carton.  After taste-testing several pints of Chocolate Fudge Brownie (just to be sure, of course), I can attest to the fact that the brownies are quite reliably very fudgy and soft.

Want a second opinion on Chocolate Fudge Brownie?  Visit On Second Scoop and read their review.

Monday, October 6, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch

My epic Ben & Jerry's Taste Test officially begins with Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch. I give this amazing flavor 5 stars because after being unable to eat ice cream or drink coffee for a torturous ten years, the creamy coffee flavor of the ice cream combined with the fudge-covered toffee pieces tastes like HEAVEN to this former coffee barista.

First of all, the toffee pieces make this flavor the epitome of a Ben & Jerry's chunky ice cream flavor.  I'm a big fan of toffee and usually end up sampling all eight flavors at the toffee maker's booth each time our local street fair sets up in town, so the chunks in Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch are a huge treat for me.  And oh, what chunks they are... these absolutely monstrous pieces of toffee are larger than pieces of anything else that I've found in any other Ben & Jerry's flavor.  Take a look at the size of the chunks that Ben & Jerry's is dumping into their batches of Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch (pictured to the right and below).




Even without the fudge-covered toffee pieces, though, I could eat a ton of this creamy coffee-flavored ice cream all day long. Or I can just take a spoonful or two at breakfast in order to sweeten the taste in my mouth and give myself a boost for the day. (My increased energy may be due to nothing more than the placebo effect, but since my stomach still isn't strong enough to hand actual coffee, I'll take it!)  I have no idea how coffee-flavored ice creams made by other brands compare to Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch, which might be worth investigating eventually. But in any event, the toffee pieces put Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch at the top of my list over any of the other flavors that I have sampled in my preliminary tastings.

My husband doesn't care for Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch, though, because he thinks the toffee pieces are too sweet.  But it's important to know that he thinks toffee is too sweet in general.  In the end, whether or not you like Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch may come down to whether or not you generally like toffee.  But for a toffee lover and/or a coffee lover, Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch is just about the best treat that I can imagine.

Want a second opinion about Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch?  Visit On Second Scoop and read their review.