.

.

Welcome to the House of Flavors

A little bit background - because of a chronic stomach condition, I haven't been able to eat ice cream in ten years. TEN YEARS. Imagine my suffering.

But after years of seeing a nutritionist and trying dozens of different diets and herbal remedies, my stomach has slowly been healing, and I am once again able to eat frozen deliciousness made from milk and cream and sugar. I am ecstatic, which I'm sure any ice cream lover can understand.

When I discovered I could once again eat ice cream without getting sick, I came up with the brilliant idea that I would undertake an epic taste test of Ben & Jerry's dozens of ice cream flavors. And starting with this original taste test, this blog is where I record and review all results of my ice cream taste testing adventures. Enjoy my rapturous observations about each delicious flavor and please feel free to share your own opinions in the comments section!
Showing posts with label Cake Flavored Ice Creams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cake Flavored Ice Creams. Show all posts

Sunday, November 16, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Cake Batter Ice Cream

During my quest to taste every currently available flavor of Ben & Jerry's, Cake Batter ice cream had become something of a Holy Grail. Although it's supposed to be just as widely available as any other flavor that comes in a pint, I haven't spotted it at any of the five local chain grocery stores where I have located every other flavor that is listed on the Ben & Jerry's website as being currently available. According to the website's Flavor Locator, there are no stores in my entire county that currently stick/sell Cake Batter - and there aren't any in the neighboring county either. It was starting to look like I was going to have to make a trip to southern New Jersey to get my hands on a pint of this stuff, and anybody who knows me knows how much I hate driving into New Jersey. The roads in NJ are extremely convoluted and the Jersey walls screw up your ability to simply turn left at an intersection or turn around if you have accidentally gone too far past your destination. I can't stand it. So of course I've been hoping that I could find another way to get some Cake Batter.

Then one day I while I was out for a walk, I decided to stop in at a random local gas station/convenience store to see what Ben & Jerry's they jad stocked in their mini-freezer. To my great excitement, they had pints of Cake Batter ice cream stacked in amongst the Red Velvet Cake, Phish Food and Half Baked. I felt a little bit like Indiana Jones, having located my very own Holy Grail. I gleefully paid for the pint, telling myself that $5 for a pint of ice cream was justifiable just this once, since I had been searching for this flavor literally for months. Then I half-ran all the way home, hoping that my precious cargo wouldn't melt too much on the way. I got it home and stuck it in the freezer, planning to sample it after dinner.

When I broke the plastic seal on the pint and pulled off the lid, I encountered a delicious sight - ample swirls of chocolate frosting running through the much-praised Vanilla Cake Batter ice cream. I eagerly scooped up the first spoonful, but as I let the ice cream roll around on my tongue, I experienced a huge let-down. My ice cream tasted like I had eaten a mouthful of sand. None of the reviews of Cake Batter that I had read on other ice cream blogs made any mention of any gritty texture at all, but my pint of Cake Batter literally tasted as though someone had dumped a bag of sand into the ice cream mixer. I flipped over the carton to check the Sell By Date and I was upset to find that the date stamped on the bottom was January 2013 - almost two years ago. I had no idea that freezer burn could ruin ice cream so completely, but clearly I need to start paying more attention to the Sell By Dates because this pint of Cake Batter was disgusting. Obviously this was an upsetting experience, particularly after having searched for this flavor for so long.

I'm happy to report, though, that the disgusting nature of that pint of Cake Batter was a fluke. After having such a difficult time locating this flavor near my home in New York, I decided I would make it my mission to find Cake Batter at a grocery store in the Washington DC metro area when we went to visit for Veteran's Day. I would scour all the Harris Teeters, Safeways and Giants until I found this elusive flavor. Except happily, I located Cake Batter at the first store that I tried. And this flavor was definitely worth the extended search.

First of all, the Vanilla Cake Batter ice cream did not disappoint. I have written before that I am not a fan of plain old Vanilla ice cream, but not all Vanilla ice creams are the same. And Vanilla Cake Batter ice cream is definitely not the same as Vanilla ice cream. There is something very distinct about the taste of Vanilla Cake Batter versus just plain old Vanilla, and Ben & Jerry's has once again gotten this taste nailed down perfectly.

And now we have to discuss the swirls of chocolate frosting. I am not sure that my descriptive powers can fully do these creamy, delicious chocolate frosting swirls the proper justice, so check out this picture -




Can you see how the chocolate frosting swirls are ooey gooey, creamy and delicious?  When stored properly in the freezer so as to avoid the horrible monster of Freezer Burn, the frosting swirls manage to retain a very soft texture despite the cold temperature.  Good job with the recipe for this one, Ben & Jerry's.  I hope you pay your food scientists very, very well.  (I'm sure that they do.)

In sum, with the flavor Cake Batter, Ben & Jerry's has really figured out how to replicate the taste of vanilla cake, which turns out to be much more exciting as an ice cream flavor instead of as a cake flavor, mashed up with frosting creamy chocolate frosting.  This is coincidentally pretty much how I like to eat my cake - with the frosting mashed around to moisten the cake. So this flavor gets 4 stars, and I am really upset that I probably won't be able to buy it on a regular basis, since I can't seem to find it at a grocery store anywhere near my home. Even so, the quest for my Ben & Jerry's Holy Grail has ended, and ended on a high note indeed.

Sunday, October 26, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake

Red Velvet Cake (the actual cake, not the Ben & Jerry's flavor) is something of a mystery. Depending on the exact recipe, red velvet cake typically contains buttermilk and cocoa.  But the mystery is that it's neither chocolate cake (although some people think that it tastes similar) or vanilla cake (although the dessert definitely contains some of that universally loved flavor).  But if it's not chocolate or vanilla cake, carrot cake or cheesecake, what flavor is it, exactly?  It tastes like... red velvet? A mouthful of fuzzy fabric that is typically used to make bell bottoms for hippies and Halloween costumes for Renaissance princess wannabes?  It's a strange name for such a delicious dessert, to say the least.

The name of the dessert seems to come not from its flavoring agents, but rather from the red food coloring that is added to the cake batter, and from the overall pleasing flavor and texture of the cake which perhaps might bring to mind the phrase "as smooth as velvet."  There's my best guess, although a little internet research yielded an additional interesting tidbit. According to Wikipedia, while most red velvet cake recipes use either red food coloring or beet juice to enhance the red tint of the cake batter, the reaction of acidic vinegar and buttermilk in the recipe reveals the red anthocyanin in cocoa - inspiring the name - and also keeps the cake moist, light and fluffy. Wikipedia doesn't mention why the dessert is called "velvet cake" though.

Despite the mystery that nags at my curiosity, Red Velvet Cake is an amazingly delicious dessert, even if it lacks a specific flavor that is readily identifiable to people without food science degrees, culinary training, or food critics with extremely refined palettes.  You don't have to be an expert in taste testing to know that this sh*t is good.

When enjoying a pint of Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake, my gastronomic experience was in fact quite similar. It's not vanilla or chocolate flavored, but it tastes remarkably like that unidentifiable delicious red velvet flavor. (My husband also suggested that it called to mind that other amorphous but beloved confection of my childhood, Funfetti Cake.)  The ice cream itself is sweet and pleasing, and then - oh rapture! - there is a cream cheese frosting swirl throughout. Since cream cheese frosting is one of my favorite ways to top off any kind of cake, my rating of Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake just shot up even further, even though the flavor of the swirl isn't overly distinct from the red velvet/funfetti cake flavor. The cream cheese frosting swirl serves more to enhance and sweeten the red velvet cake base, blending together to produce a fun dessert flavor. This flavor isn't as decadent and heavy as many of the B&J's flavors that I typically love, which often contain various more highly caloric combinations of chocolate and peanut butter, but it's nice to find a flavor that I enjoy so much that provides variety in my usual lineup.

The one downside to this flavor is the chunks of actual red velvet cake, which don't seem to take too kindly to being frozen. While the hearty chunks of brownie in Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Fudge Brownie are nice and gooey, these chunks of red velvet cake are more dry and don't seem to retain the original flavor of the cake very well. This makes sense, though, when you consider that brownies are more dense and would hold their moisture better than red velvet cake, which is lighter and fluffier. I would venture to guess that brownies are just better suited for inclusion in ice cream than a cake that is supposed to be airy and fluffy.

That flaw aside, Ben & Jerry's Red Velvet Cake gets 4.5 stars and is pretty high up on my list of favorite flavors. Kudos to Ben & Jerry's for creating such an accurate reproduction of a mysterious flavor.

Sunday, October 19, 2014

Ben & Jerry's Volun-Tiramisu

I had to sample Ben & Jerry's Volun-Tiramisu several times across the span of more than a week to decide exactly what I thought about this flavor. That's pretty unusual - typically I like to have a couple of servings before I fully decide how many stars to give to an ice cream in order to confirm my initial reaction, but sometimes I can even decide after one sitting what I think and feel about an ice cream flavor. The flavors that I dislike are almost harder, though. I feel a certain loyalty to Ben & Jerry's, and it's almost as though I want to like a flavor so much that I force myself to try it several times before I can admit to myself that I just don't like it.  Volun-Tiramisu is the extreme example of my near inability to admit that Ben & Jerry's has come up with a dud.

The "coffee mascarpone ice cream with cocoa dusted coffee rum lady finger pieces" seems like it would be a good idea, and maybe I would like the coffee mascarpone ice cream itself, without the lady fingers.  It even seems like a very likely possibility to me that I would enjoy a flavor like that immensely.  But alas, we'll never know, because those dry, somewhat chalky tasting lady fingers are mixed indiscriminately throughout the ice cream, leaving no opportunity for me to fully appreciate the coffee mascarpone flavor.  Every time I sampled the pint, I came away with a strange sort of dry, gritty taste in my mouth.

Ben & Jerry's, you should know better. The pieces or chunks in your ice cream, while one of my favorite parts of the B&J's experience, need to be at least somewhat moist to blend well with the ice cream.  The best examples of the most successful Ben & Jerry's chunks include the moist cookie dough in both Half Baked and Cookie Dough ice cream, the brownie chunks in both Half Baked and Chocolate Fudge Brownie, the fudge and walnut chunks in Chunky Monkey, the toffee pieces in Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch,  and the fudge running throughout many of the new 2014 Core flavors. While the toffee, fudge chunks and walnuts aren't as moist as the brownies, cookie dough and fudge core, they are meant to be harder and give the ice cream more of a crunch. The toffee, walnuts and fudge chunks are by no means dry, though, and they don't interrupt your experience of the creamy ice cream. Even the somewhat gritty cookie swirl blended throughout Milk & Cookies manages to be moist and pleasing. But the lady fingers in Volun-Tiramisu just make the entirety or each spoonful a somewhat strange, dry experience, earning this flavor 2 stars and a grimace.

Special note: this flavor is carried exclusively at Target.