Ben & Jerry's Salted Caramel Core

Whoever believes that "you can never have too much of a good thing" has clearly never encountered the paradox of the Ben & Jerry's flavor Salted Caramel Core.  On the one hand, the caramel core running through the center of this pint is like an amazingly delicious gob of the caramel sauce that is used to make caramel apples on a stick. Yum, right? Well, not if you get too big a mouthful. Then it's just overwhelmingly sweet. The kind of sweet that can be headache-inducing. When I first cracked open a pint of Salted Caramel Core, I made the mistake of scooping up a spoonful of the caramel core, and not only did it give me an instant buzz, it dulled my tastebuds so that they were unable to appreciate the more subtle Sweet Cream flavor. I got a mouthful of caramel, followed by what seemed to be bland, almost tasteless ice cream. I guess you could say that my poor tastebuds were in shock.

Round Two with my pint of Salted Caramel Core was a much different experience.  I was determined to fully enjoy Ben & Jerry's combination of "Sweet Cream ice cream with Blonde Brownies and a Salted Caramel Core."  So I employed a new strategy - I scooped out a spoonful of the ice cream and added just a small dollop of the caramel core. As my husband has observed several times, the beautiful thing about Ben & Jerry's Core flavors is that they are customizable - you can scoop up as much (or as little) of the core as you would like to go with your ice cream. Sure enough, once I had the correct balence between the Sweet Cream and the Caramel, this flavor was a very tasty experience.

Final verdict? I give Salted Caramel Core a  4 star rating, although as I am compiling my personal ranking of all the Ben & Jerry's flavors that I have tried, this one ends up on the lower end of the list. I'm a big fan of Sweet Cream ice cream and the caramel is of course quite delicious, but in my opinion, caramel gets even better when combined with chocolate to get the downright amazing Ben & Jerry's flavor Vanilla Caramel Fudge. So this is a solid flavor, but in the end, not one of my favorites.

If you want a real mouth orgasm, though, make yourself a Sundae with Salted Caramel Core and Cinnamon Buns,  one of my all-time favorite Ben & Jerry's flavors. The combination of the caramel and the cinnamon is absolutely stunning.

Ben & Jerry's Mango Mango Sorbet

After having had Ben & Jerry's Lemonade Sorbet when I was in Alexandria, Virginia, I was eager to try more of B&J's sorbet as soon as possible. So it was time for another visit to the scoop shop. Since I love mangoes, I decided Mango Mango Sorbet would be the way to go, which turned out to be an excellent decision.

In comparison to Ben & Jerry's Lemonade Sorbet, which is tangy, Mango Mango Sorbet is sweeter and also quite refreshing. I was impressed once again how the B&J's Flavor Gurus have been able to replicate the flavor of a mango so accurately - I felt basically as though I was eating actual frozen fruit instead of sorbet. Because the flavor is so simple - and simplicity seems to be the key with sorbet - there isn't much more to say about Mango Mango Sorbet. It's tasty, it's refreshing, it geta 4.5 delicious stars. Well done once again, Ben & Jerry's. Well done.

Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup

If you follow this blog at all, you know that I passionately adore chunky ice creams. That is one of my favorite things about Ben & Jerry's ice cream in particular - that they have incorporated so many fun textures and chunky pieces into their signature flavors, making them more unique than other ice cream brands in my estimation. But I have to admit that sometimes very chunky ice creams have a major downfall - if a particular flavor of ice cream is too hard packed and/or the chunks are too large, it can be extremely difficult to dig up a spoonful, and even more frustrating to enjoy an entire serving.

This was the challenge that I encountered when I first opened a pint of Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup, and it felt as though the delicious Peanut Butter ice cream and chunks of Reese's Peanut Butter Cups were taunting me. (Although technically, I don't think they are actually Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, but they are exactly the same.) The Peanut Butter ice cream was dense and hard packed that I could hardly dig my spoon into the pint, and the Peanut Butter Cups were so large that when I encountered one I had to entirely give up on scooping it out. After all, the peanut butter cups are pretty much whole and intact, the same size as Reese's mini Peanut Butter Cups. Those Reese's minis may seem small when you are just grabbing one or two for a snack, but one of those is definitely a tiny, manageable chunk to encounter in your pint of ice cream. I was determined to come up with a solution, though. Reese's Peanut Butter Cups are one of my favorite treats, aside from ice cream, and plus one of my friends had recommended this particular flavor to me as being one of her favorites. Clearly if I could figure out how to scoop this flavor more easily, it would be worth my time and effort.

This is how I discovered the secret to eating extremely chunky ice cream. The proper way to go about enjoying this type of dance, hard packed ice cream with huge, even unmanageable chunks, is quite simple. Take the pint out of the freezer and leave it on the counter for five to ten minutes before you start to eat it. The ice cream becomes softer and more malleable, but its still cold and enjoyable.

Once I let my pint of Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup soften a bit, it was every bit as delicious as my friend had said. The concept for this flavor is not very complicated - Reese's Peanut Butter Cups buried in Peanut Butter ice cream. Simple, yes. But amazing all the same.

The one downside to this flavor is that because of the huge pieces of Reese's peanut butter cups, the calories per serving for this flavor is particularly high, at 340 calories for a half a cup. (That is in comparison to 270 to 300 calories per serving for many Ben & Jerry's flavors.) But the nice thing with this flavor is that because of the huge chunks, you can really take your time to enjoy a single serving. Because huge chunks in my ice cream tend to slow me down, I ended up being able to control a lot better how much of this flavor I ate at once, and enjoyed about a half a serving at a time without feeling like I had to have more. With some Ben & Jerry's flavors, I want to keep eating and eating. I can demolish a half of a pint or more without too much thought. But with this flavor, the Reese's Peanut Butter Cups are very rich. Even when I am eating them by themselves, I can usually enjoy just one or two mini cups at a time. So having four or five Reese's minis surrounded by delicious cold ice cream is plenty of a treat for me, and tallies up to about 200 calories.

Since I love Reese's Peanut Butter Cups so much, I am willing to forgive the higher caloric content of this flavor and I give it 5 stars. Definitely not an everyday treat, but that almost makes it even better. When I do pull out a pint of Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup, it is a true treat.

Ben & Jerry's Cake Batter Ice Cream

During my quest to taste every currently available flavor of Ben & Jerry's, Cake Batter ice cream had become something of a Holy Grail. Although it's supposed to be just as widely available as any other flavor that comes in a pint, I haven't spotted it at any of the five local chain grocery stores where I have located every other flavor that is listed on the Ben & Jerry's website as being currently available. According to the website's Flavor Locator, there are no stores in my entire county that currently stick/sell Cake Batter - and there aren't any in the neighboring county either. It was starting to look like I was going to have to make a trip to southern New Jersey to get my hands on a pint of this stuff, and anybody who knows me knows how much I hate driving into New Jersey. The roads in NJ are extremely convoluted and the Jersey walls screw up your ability to simply turn left at an intersection or turn around if you have accidentally gone too far past your destination. I can't stand it. So of course I've been hoping that I could find another way to get some Cake Batter.

Then one day I while I was out for a walk, I decided to stop in at a random local gas station/convenience store to see what Ben & Jerry's they jad stocked in their mini-freezer. To my great excitement, they had pints of Cake Batter ice cream stacked in amongst the Red Velvet Cake, Phish Food and Half Baked. I felt a little bit like Indiana Jones, having located my very own Holy Grail. I gleefully paid for the pint, telling myself that $5 for a pint of ice cream was justifiable just this once, since I had been searching for this flavor literally for months. Then I half-ran all the way home, hoping that my precious cargo wouldn't melt too much on the way. I got it home and stuck it in the freezer, planning to sample it after dinner.

When I broke the plastic seal on the pint and pulled off the lid, I encountered a delicious sight - ample swirls of chocolate frosting running through the much-praised Vanilla Cake Batter ice cream. I eagerly scooped up the first spoonful, but as I let the ice cream roll around on my tongue, I experienced a huge let-down. My ice cream tasted like I had eaten a mouthful of sand. None of the reviews of Cake Batter that I had read on other ice cream blogs made any mention of any gritty texture at all, but my pint of Cake Batter literally tasted as though someone had dumped a bag of sand into the ice cream mixer. I flipped over the carton to check the Sell By Date and I was upset to find that the date stamped on the bottom was January 2013 - almost two years ago. I had no idea that freezer burn could ruin ice cream so completely, but clearly I need to start paying more attention to the Sell By Dates because this pint of Cake Batter was disgusting. Obviously this was an upsetting experience, particularly after having searched for this flavor for so long.

I'm happy to report, though, that the disgusting nature of that pint of Cake Batter was a fluke. After having such a difficult time locating this flavor near my home in New York, I decided I would make it my mission to find Cake Batter at a grocery store in the Washington DC metro area when we went to visit for Veteran's Day. I would scour all the Harris Teeters, Safeways and Giants until I found this elusive flavor. Except happily, I located Cake Batter at the first store that I tried. And this flavor was definitely worth the extended search.

First of all, the Vanilla Cake Batter ice cream did not disappoint. I have written before that I am not a fan of plain old Vanilla ice cream, but not all Vanilla ice creams are the same. And Vanilla Cake Batter ice cream is definitely not the same as Vanilla ice cream. There is something very distinct about the taste of Vanilla Cake Batter versus just plain old Vanilla, and Ben & Jerry's has once again gotten this taste nailed down perfectly.

And now we have to discuss the swirls of chocolate frosting. I am not sure that my descriptive powers can fully do these creamy, delicious chocolate frosting swirls the proper justice, so check out this picture -

Can you see how the chocolate frosting swirls are ooey gooey, creamy and delicious?  When stored properly in the freezer so as to avoid the horrible monster of Freezer Burn, the frosting swirls manage to retain a very soft texture despite the cold temperature.  Good job with the recipe for this one, Ben & Jerry's.  I hope you pay your food scientists very, very well.  (I'm sure that they do.)

In sum, with the flavor Cake Batter, Ben & Jerry's has really figured out how to replicate the taste of vanilla cake, which turns out to be much more exciting as an ice cream flavor instead of as a cake flavor, mashed up with frosting creamy chocolate frosting.  This is coincidentally pretty much how I like to eat my cake - with the frosting mashed around to moisten the cake. So this flavor gets 4 stars, and I am really upset that I probably won't be able to buy it on a regular basis, since I can't seem to find it at a grocery store anywhere near my home. Even so, the quest for my Ben & Jerry's Holy Grail has ended, and ended on a high note indeed.

Ben & Jerry's Lemonade Sorbet

As I have explained in my last few posts, my husband and I went to Washington DC over the weekend to visit friends, and I was thrilled to find that the Ben & Jerry's Scoop Shop in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia, had a bunch of flavors that I haven't tasted yet. You can imagine my excitement.

My tasting of Lemonade Sorbet was my first encounter with Ben & Jerry's sorbet, and it only made me crave more. Whereas B&J's Liz Lemon Greek Froyo is lighter than many of their rich ice creams, Lemonade Sorbet was positively refreshing. If you think that all lemon flavorings are the same, you absolutely need to taste these two desserts. Compared to Liz Lemon, which is still fairly sweet due to the Blueberry Lavender swirl, Lemonade Sorbet has a distinctly tangy flavor that would be my favorite choice for a truly hot summer day. It was a little amazing to me how accurately this sorbet replicates not just the flavor of lemons, but specifically the flavor of lemonade. There isn't anything creamy about this flavor at all - it tastes like pure, icey fruitiness. Because the flavor is so simple, I can't think of much more to say, except that for its tangy, refreshing quality, Lemonade Sorbet gets 4.5 stars. This will probably be my go-to flavor in July and August next year, when the temperature climbs past 90 and I need something to cool me down.

Oh, and have I mentioned yet that I also picked up some fun Ben & Jerry's lip balm while I was at the scoop shop in Alexandria? The balm itself isn't anything special - I think I would rather use Lipsmackers if I wanted some chocolate flavored chapstick, to be honest. But because I love my B&J's so much, it was worth $2 a pot to have the cute little Ben & Jerry's lip balm.

Ben & Jerry's Two Wild & Crazy Pies

As I have explained in several of my previous posts, my husband and I went to Washington DC for the weekend over the Veteran's Day holiday. Since Ben & Jerry's scoop shops aren't exactly abundant right where we live, of course I had to see whether or not there was a scoop shop near where our friends live. I was thrilled to discover that not only is there an awesome Ben & Jerry's Scoop Shop nearby in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia, but that they had a TON of flavors that I had not yet tasted. Since we were visiting over a four day weekend, we decided that we would visit the scoop shop several times so I could knock out as many flavors as possible. My friends were happy to indulge me, as you can see in the photo below -

On one trip to the Old Town scoop shop, I decided to order Two Wild & Crazy Pies, one of Ben & Jerry's Saturday Night Live flavors. This flavor combines coconut cream and chocolate cream pie ice creams with a chocolate cookie swirl. Now it's important to note that I have already taste tested Ben & Jerry's Coconut Seven Layer Bar ice cream, and I was not a fan. That flavor had too much coconut and not much else to balance it out or make it more rich. As I sampled Coconut Seven Layer Bar, I almost reached the conclusion that I didn't like coconut in my ice cream at all. But then I had the thought that if the flavor had some chocolate, then I would probably really enjoy the coconut in the ice cream. Having since read the description of Two Wild & Crazy Pies, I was curious to see whether or not my idea was correct - do I or do I not like coconut in ice cream when it is combined with other flavors (particularly chocolate)?

My reaction to Two Wild & Crazy Pies was so positive that it took me by surprised. I expected to enjoy the flavor, but not necessary that this one would make it into my Top Ten list. Yet the combination of chocolate amd coconut, with the chocolate clearly dominating and the coconut playing a supporting role, is extremely delicious and also gets points for being quite different from other ice cream flavors. The Oreo cookie swirl, which adds even more chocolate deliciousness to an already tasty combination, tops off this flavor to make it entirely unique. Two Wild & Crazy Pies gets a 5 star rating and, as I said, a spot in my Top Ten Ben & Jerry's Flavors. I would keep it stocked in my freezer on a regular basis, except for the fact that it's only available in scoop shops and my own local scoop shop doesn't seem to carry it. I guess I'm going to have to start a campaign to get Ben & Jerry's to carry Two Wild & Crazy Pies in a pint, because otherwise I may go into withdrawal.

Ben & Jerry's Mint Chocolate Chunk

As I explained in a few of my previous posts, my husband and I came to Washington DC for the weekend to visit friends in the area, and I was thrilled to find that the Ben & Jerry's Scoop Shop in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia, had a TON of flavors that I haven't tasted yet. Since we are visiting over a four day weekend, we decided that we would visit the scoop shop several times so that I could properly sample multiple flavors. As you can see in the photo below, my husband and friends are clearly making a huge sacrifice so that I can give the proper attention to my taste testing.

As you can see, we have spent some time making friends with the local Ben & Jerry's cow.  And we have also enjoyed ourselves tasting 10+ flavors of my favorite ice creamy goodness. While I definitely sampled many of the flavors that are unique to Ben & Jerry's such as White Russian, Two Wild & Crazy Pies and Turtle Cheesecake, I sampled a couple of their more basic flavors as well, just so that I could say that I have had those flavors at least once.

Mint Chocolate Chunk was one of those flavors that I felt like it was obligatory for me to taste, and I didn't receive any surprises. As the Ben & Jerry's version of Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream, it's a solid choice if your tastes tend toward the more traditional. The mint ice cream is tasty, although no more so than any other Mint Chocolate Chip that I've had. It is the larger chunks of chocolate that make the Ben & Jerry's more tasty than other brands with tiny chocolate chips, in my opinion. I like the more-chocolate of the Mint Chocolate options.

But after having Mint Chocolate Cookie ice cream, Ben & Jerry's other variation on the traditional Mint Chocolate Chip flavor, my final judgment is that the Mint Chocolate Cookie is the best of all these similar options. I like the mint ice cream with the Oreo cookies even better than the mint ice cream with big chocolate chunks. So while I rated Mint Chocolate Cookie 4 stars, I'm only giving Mint Chocolate Chunk 3 stars - it loses points for lack of originality. Maybe my expectations are too high, but I feel strongly that the best part of Ben & Jerry's ice cream is the originality of their flavors - something that Mint Chocolate Chunk is clearly lacking.

Ben & Jerry's Turtle Cheesecake

As I explained in my last blog post, my husband and I came to visit friends in the Washington DC area and of cpurse I had to check amd see if there were any Ben & Jerry's scoop shops nearby. I was thrilled to find a scoop shop in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia, that had a TON of flavors that I haven't tasted yet. Since we are visiting for a four day weekend, we decided that we would make the most of the opportunity and visit the scoop shop several times so that I could properly sample multiple flavors. And my friends have undoubtedly been enjoying themselves, accompanying me on my quest to try each Ben & Jerry's flavor.

As for the taste testing, I wanted to try a combination of basic flavors such as Mint Chocolate Chunk and Mango Sorbet, as well as several more unusual, signature Ben & Jerry's Ben & Jerry's flavors such as their Saturday Night Live-inspired "Two Wild & Crazy Pies."  But I've really enjoyed sampling several of Ben & Jerry's other cheesecake ice cream flavors, so I've been eager to try Turtle Cheesecake.  Therefore I was particularly excited to find that the Old Town scoop shop carried this flavor. So how does Turtle Cheesecake compare to Strawberry Cheesecake and Pumpkin Cheesecake?
 

First of all, cheesecake doesn't actually seem to be the dominant flavor of Ben & Jerry's Pumpkin Cheesecake ice cream, so I feel like the real comparison is between the cheesecake ice cream in Strawberry Cheesecake and Turtle Cheesecake. As I wrote in my post on Strawberry Cheesecake, the cheesecake in this flavor is more like a tasty "lite" cheesecake dessert, as opposed to a rich piece of cheesecake that I would buy at a bakery or The Cheesecake Factory. This isn't necessarily a disappointment, but a richer cheesecake ice cream would score higher for me. Even though I enjoy lighter flavored ice creams and sorbets, my preference usually leans towards rich flavors with chocolate, caramel, toffee, peanut butter, etc. To someone with my preferences, the cheesecake + chocolate + caramel combination in Turtle Cheesecake sounds utterly delicious, even rich enough to be comparable to something that I could order at The Cheesecake Factory.

After taste testing Ben & Jerry's Turtle Cheesecake, I can confirm that not only is the cheesecake ice cream itself more rich than in Strawberry Cheesecake, but the addition of caramel and chocolate also make this flavor a much more rich concoction than the other Ben & Jerry's cheesecake flavors. And while Strawberry Cheesecake and Pumpkin Cheesecake both have a graham cracker swirl, Turtle Cheesecake skips replicating a graham cracker crust in favor of not only fudge chunks and a caramel swirl, but pecans as well. So even though the graham cracker swirl is the hoghlight of the other Ben & Jerry's cheesecake ice creams, I didn't end up missing it in Turtle Cheesecake. There are plenty of goodies in this delicious flavor to satisfy anyone with a taste for rich flavors. In fact, at 4.5 stars, my rating for Turtle Cheesecake is higher than my rating for Strawberry Cheesecake precisely because I prefer rich flavors. And it would be hard to go wrong when combining so many of my favorites - cheesecake, chocolate amd caramel. Yummmmm.

Ben & Jerry's White Russian Ice Cream

My husband and I came to Washington DC for the weekend to visit friends in the area, and I was thrilled to find that the Ben & Jerry's Scoop Shop in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia, had a TON of flavors that I haven't tasted yet. Since we are visiting over a four day weekend, we decided that we would visit the scoop shop several times so that I could properly sample multiple flavors.

On our first visit, we made friends with two very cool scoop shop employees, who were interested in my blog and were more than willing to discuss ice cream textures and flavors with me. We had a great time with them, as you can see -

As for the actual taste testing, after weighing my options, I decided to try the White Russian flavor, since it's supposedly very hard to locate. It was discontinued at one point, then revived as a scoop shop flavor, but I've found comments online indicating that many people think that it's still unavailable because they haven't been able to find it. So I thought it would be better to try this flavor while it's within my power to do so.

For all the hype, though, White Russian didn't turn out to be all that exciting. It's a coffee flavored ice cream with a coffee liqueur. That sounds pretty tasty, but the flavor turned out to be extremely similar to that of plain old Coffee ice cream. So similar, in fact, that my new friends at the Alexandria Ben & Jerry's tell me that most people can't tell the difference at all. I noticed one major difference, though - a grittier texture. The ladies behind the counter tell me that this gritty texture has something to do with the liqueur. I didn't think it was a positive addition to the flavor, honestly. Especially because I had just recently sampled Coffee Caramel Buzz, which has amazingly delicious Whiskey Caramel Swirls, I am aware that yummy alcoholic flavor can be added to ice cream with much better results. Therefore, White Russian gets a 2 star rating... but the Old Town Alexandria Ben & Jerry's Scoop Shop gets a 5 star rating.

Ben & Jerry's Coffee Caramel Buzz

After falling in love with Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch, I wasn't sure if other coffee ice creams could even begin to compare with that delicious flavor, but I shouldn't have doubted the Ben & Jerry's Flavor Gurus. And after reading the description of Coffee Caramel Buzz, I was certainly more inclined to think that Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch might have a rival for my affections. "Coffee malt ice cream with whiskey caramel swirls and English toffee pieces" definitely sounds tempting. So I threw the pint into my shopping cart and away I went to sample and compare Coffee Caramel Buzz versus Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch.

Let's start off with a discussion of the Coffee Malt ice cream flavor. While not bad at all, I have to admit that this flavor doesn't do it for me the way that the richer flavor of the plain old coffee ice cream in Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch absolutely sends me to heaven. The malt seems to repress the richness of the coffee flavor, although admittedly that may have been a purposeful choice to balance out the other elements of this flavor, which are indeed quite rich.

And that brings us to the Whiskey Caramel Swirls. Let's just stop and take a minute to savor that phrase - Whiskey Caramel Swirls. These swirls are every bit as heavenly as they sound, with an alcoholic flavor that definitely differentiates these caramel swirls from other caramel swirls in flavors such as Phish Food and my beloved Vanilla Caramel Fudge. The taste is deliciously unique - or at least I've never sampled anything quite like it in an ice cream flavor. My only complaint is that the veins of Whiskey Caramel Swirl aren't as ubiquitous in this flavor as the caramel swirls in the aforementioned Phish Food and Vanilla Caramel Fudge. There seem to be vast deserts of Coffee Malt ice cream left uncrossed by Whiskey Caramel, crying out for more flavor. Of course, more Whiskey Caramel would mean more calories per serving, but some sacrifices are totally worth it.

Aside from the unique element of the Whiskey Caramel Swirl, Coffee Caramel Buzz also has the same delicious chocolate covered toffee pieces as are found in Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch. And in case you don't remember the gratuitous toffee porn from my post on that other flavor, check out this picture of the chocolate covered toffee pieces that Ben & Jerry's adds to their ice creams -

Yes, the toffee chunks really are that big, and they are fabulous. Of course, as I likewise mentioned in my post about Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch, if you're not a big fan of toffee to begin with, you're not going to be excited about these ginormous pieces. And be forewarned - even if you do like toffee, you may not enjoy having to strenuously dig such large chunks of anything out of your ice cream. Most of the pieces are honestly an inch in diameter. But as I have explained before, I really enjoy the experience of eating chunky ice creams - I feel as though I am on a treasure hunt, and having to dig out huge chunks makes me slow down and savor the flavor even further.

So to recap - I'm not a huge fan of the Coffee Malt ice cream base, but I love the Whiskey Caramel Swirls and chocolate covered English Toffee pieces.  I only wish there were more plentiful swirls throughout the pint. Because I enjoy the coffee ice cream base in Coffee Toffee Bar Crunch, Coffee Caramel Buzz remains lower on my list, but it still earns a solid 4 star rating. There are definitely times that I would choose that Whiskey Caramel Swirl over the coffee ice cream.

Ben & Jerry's Chocolate Peppermint Crunch

Chocolate Peppermint Crunch is Ben & Jerry's latest foray into the territory of chocolate and mint flavor combinations - an ongoing experiment with this traditionally popular combo that has included the now-retired flavors Chocolate Mint & Cookies, Chocolate Mystic Mint, Mint Chocolate Chunk, Mint Chocolate Fudge Swirl, Mint Fudge and Mint with Oreo Cookie, as well as the currently available flavor Mint Chocolate Cookie. Looking over this list, you might begin to wonder why Ben & Jerry's has gone through so many variations on the same chocolate and mint theme, but I would venture to guess that it's not because any of these flavors failed to sell. Ben and Jerry simply seem to enjoy working and reworking a combination, like cooks who change the spices in the stew just a little bit each time. And while most Mint Chocolate Chip ice creams produced by most ice cream manufacturers are pretty much interchangeable with all other Mint Chocolate Chip ice creams, the two Ben & Jerry's chocolate and mint flavors that I have now sampled are both a great deal different from your average carton of Mint Chocolate Chip.

I first sampled Mint Chocolate Cookie, which with its small chunks and crushed bits of Oreo is a few steps up from plain Jane Mint Chocolate Chip. Seeing a second chocolate and mint combo on the market at the same time made me curious to find out what the difference was between Mint Chocolate Cookie and Chocolate Peppermint Crunch, simce both combine chocolate, peppermint, fudge and cookie elements. Time for an exercise in Compare and Contrast.

As I sampled Chocolate Peppermint Crunch, two notable differences presented themselves. First of all, while Mint Chocolate Cookie has a mint ice cream base just like the traditional Mint Chocolate Chip flavor, Chocolate Peppermint Crunch has a chocolate ice cream base with peppermint and fudge swirls running throughout. While the fudge swirl do not stand out in any discernible way from the chocolate ice cream itself, the peppermint swirl have the effect of basically turning the base flavor into a delicious hybrid of chocolate peppermint ice cream. I'm definitely a fan.

The second difference that I noticed with this flavor is the presence of the mint chocolate cookie balls. I was expecting that the cookie balls would probably resemble the softer cookie dough in Half Baked, the cookie swirls in Milk & Cookies, or the Oreo cookie in Mint Chocolate Cookie. But this is where Ben & Jerry's has made a big change that makes this flavor a lot more of a fun experience to sample. Like Chubby Hubby, eating Chocolate Peppermint Crunch makes me feel as though I am going on a treasure hunt. Because the cookie balls are actually about as big as malted milk balls and as crunchy as the pretzel pieces in Chubby Hubby, you end up really having to dig your way through the pint of Chocolate Peppermint Crunch.  It takes something of an effort to scoop out those cookie balls, but for those of us who enjoy that kind of thing, Chocolate Peppermint Crunch is a whole lot of fun to eat.  You actually end up chomping on this frozen dairy delight.

As for the balance between chocolate and mint, Ben & Jerry's has done an excellent job yet again of finding the perfect blend between the two flavors. As I explained in my original review of mint chocolate cookie, I am very picky about the peppermint to chocolate ratio in my chocolate and mint desserts. I adore Thin Mints and Andes Mints, but there is too much nasty peppermint paste in York Peppermint Patties amd Ghirardelli Chocolate Peppermint Squares for my taste. So I am very pleased that Ben & Jerry's seems to understand the proper ratio between the two flavors that will please my taste buds.  Of the two B&J's mint and chocolate flavors that are currently on the market, I like this one even better than Mint Chocolate Cookie because it's more chocolatey. The best description that I can come up with to describe this delicious flavor is that it is like Christmas in my mouth, and that is high praise indeed, coming from someone who loves Christmas as much as I do.

Because of the excellent job combining chocolate and mint, and even more because those crunchy cookie balls make this flavor so much fun to eat, I give Chocolate Peppermint Crunch 4.5 stars.  This is another chunky paragon of the Ben & Jerry's brand that joyfully reinvents I tradition and makes my mission to sample all of their flavors so much fun.

Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge

I have to admit that when I first saw the pint of Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge, I wasn't very excited. Sure I love caramel, and sure I love fudge, but a lot of Ben & Jerry's flavors have caramel and fudge - and then some. And vanilla ice cream? Yawn. Nine times out of ten, give me chocolate ice cream, peanut butter ice cream, sweet cream ice cream... any ice cream but vanilla ice cream. Vanilla Caramel Fudge seemed too simple, like a cop out from the Ben & Jerry's Flavor Gurus. "They're just phoning it in," I thought.

But then I had a flash of memory.  Images recollected from high school of happy visits to the local Baskin Robbins with groups of my friends.  We would walk down the block from the school after play rehearsal or over to the shop on boring Sunday afternoons.  I remember staring down into the bucket of the flavor called "Gold Medal Ribbon" with anticipation as the employee scooped my order, a flavor aptly named because it had decent-sized ribbons of chocolate and caramel running through the vanilla ice cream.  Gold Medal Ribbon was my favorite flavor of ice cream for several years when I was growing up in Michigan, a time when I didn't have a job and it seemed like I was always pulling the very last few dollars from my wallet and scrounging for some coins at the bottom of my purse to pay for my scoop. Good times. (Someone over at Baskin Robbins R&D obviously did a bang up job developing and naming that flavor, since it has stuck with me for nearly fifteen years.)

Now, as a thirty-one year-old (or am I thirty-two now??) with credit cards and a paycheck to support my ice cream consumption, I found myself standing in a grocery store in New York and holding a pint of Ben & Jerry's Vanilla Caramel Fudge that sounds like the exact same flavor that I loved as a teenager. With my husband trying to move me along out of the dangerous freezer section, I gave in to nostalgia, throwing the Vanilla Caramel Fudge into my shopping cart instead of the more exciting-sounding New York Super Fudge Chunk. I wanted to see how the Ben & Jerry's flavor compared to my rose-colored memory of Gold Medal Ribbon.

And oh sweet Moses, I will never be preemptively dismissive of a simple flavor combination again, because Vanilla Caramel Fudge is a mouth orgasm that I never want to forget.  The vanilla ice cream turns out to actually be the ideal base for the generous veins of ooey gooey caramel and fudge that wind their way through the pint.  And by generous, I mean ubiquitous.  Sometimes the photos of their flavors that Ben & Jerry's posts on their website are much more chunky or filled with thicker ribbons or swirls than you actually get when you by a pint off the shelf of the average grocery store down the street.  But this photo (left) is not an exaggeration in the slightest.  As you can see from this photo that I snapped, there really are that many thick, delicious veins of caramel and fudge running through the pint -

Best of all, the caramel manages to remain soft in the freezer, as do the ribbons of fudge, which resemble chocolate sauce. In short, eating from a pint of Vanilla Caramel Fudge is like going to a scoop shop and having a sundae doused liberally with caramel and fudge sauce, only better because the veins running through the whole pint ensure that you don't eat up all the chocolate sauce and find yourself with a lump of plain vanilla ice cream still melting in your bowl. Having the fudge and caramel mixed directly in and throughout the ice cream ensures the perfect rich balance of all the flavors.  The combination reminds me of Ben & Jerry's Phish Food flavor, but I actually even prefer Vanilla Caramel Fudge because the vanilla ice cream keeps the flavor from becoming too rich and lets the caramel take the stage more equally with the chocolate fudge flavor.

Because of this perfect harmony between the two, as well as my general love of chocolate and caramel combinations, I give this flavor 5 stars and a permanent spot in my freezer.

Ben & Jerry's Mint Chocolate Cookie

After falling in love with their Milk & Cookies flavor, with its genius blend of Oreo cookie swirl and chocolate chip cookie swirl, I decided that I needed to prioritize taste testing any other variations on the traditional Cookies & Cream flavor invented by the Ben & Jerry's Flavor Gurus. So over the weekend, I picked up a pint of Mint Chocolate Cookie.  And I realized that Ben & Jerry's may have a few basic flavors like Vanilla, Chocolate and Strawberry, but clearly they aren't content to simply produce your basic Cookies & Cream with chunks of Oreo in vanilla ice cream.  Instead, they've come up with Mint Chocolate Cookie - ground up Oreo cookies in peppermint ice cream.

I honestly wasn't sure whether or not I would enjoy this flavor because on the one hand, I have never liked plain Peppermint or Peppermint Stick ice creams. All by its lonesome, the peppermint flavor is too strong for my tastes. On the other hand, I absolutely adore the combination of Mint and Chocolate. Thin Mints, Mint Chocolate M & Ms, Andes Mints, even Mint Chocolate Clif Protein Bars. The Bath & Body Works Mint Chocolate candle from their 2013 Holiday Traditions product line is the most amazing thing I have ever smelled. (Sometimes I even fall asleep cuddling my Mint Chocolate candle, no joke.)  I am not so much fond of York Peppermint Patties, Ghirardelli Peppermint Squares or Mint Chocolate Fudge, though. The balence between the Mint and the Chocolate has to be right. The Chocolate needs to temper the Peppermint. The Mint cannot overwhelm the Chocolate or be too pasty tasting, like the mint in York Patties. Junior Mints are downright disgusting because of the similarly overwhelming pasty peppermint filling, but despite the dominance of mint flavor, traditional Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream works for me somehow.  I think my enjoyment of that flavor has at least something to do with the difference between peppermint and mint.  But you get the picture - Ben & Jerry's Mint Chocolate Cookie flavor has a lot of promise, but will only be successful by my judgment if the Ben & Jerry's Flavor Gurus have achieved the proper balance between the Mint and the Chocolate flavors.

After the first bite, I felt like jumping up, clacking a pair of castinets and shouting,"By George, I think she's got it!"  I felt nearly as ecstatic as Rex Harrison when Audrey Hepburn manages to correctly pronounce the phrase, "The rain in Spain stays mainly in the plain." (Insert joyous musical theater dance number here.)

Mint Chocolate Cookie is like the perfectly blended love child of those two all-time favorite traditional ice cream flavors, Mint Chocolate Chip amd Cookies & Cream. I really can't think of a better way to describe this flavor or much more to add, since Mint Chocolate Cookie isn't an overly complex concoction like some of Ben & Jerry's other ice creams. The reason that I find this flavor to be a satisfying treat is that the Flavor Gurus got the blend of Chocolate and Mint just right.  I don't love this flavor quite as much as I love Milk & Cookies because the ground up Oreos in Mint Chocolate Cookie aren't as rich as the blend of Oreos and chocolate chip cookies in M&C, but this flavor still gets a solid 4 stars.  I would definitely choose a pint of Mint Chocolate Cookie over plain old Mint Chocolate Chip any day.